The informal economy represents a paradox at the heart of many developing nations, including Pakistan. Often overlooked in official statistics yet deeply embedded in the socio-economic fabric, it sustains livelihoods, fosters resilience, and absorbs shocks during economic downturns. However, its unregulated nature also inhibits growth, weakens tax structures, and perpetuates labor exploitation. As Pakistan grapples with economic crisis, understanding whether the informal sector is a covert strength or a chronic liability becomes critical for policy, reform, and national development.
Follow CPF WhatsApp Channel for Daily Exam Updates
Cssprepforum, led by Sir Syed Kazim Ali, supports 70,000+ monthly aspirants with premium CSS/PMS prep. Follow our WhatsApp Channel for daily CSS/PMS updates, solved past papers, expert articles, and free prep resources.
Pakistan's informal economy is vast, employing more than 70% of the labor force and contributing significantly to GDP, albeit unofficially. From street vendors and home-based workers to small-scale manufacturers and service providers, this shadow sector fills the vacuum left by limited formal employment and inefficient governance. Historically rooted in socio-economic inequality, limited access to formal credit, and weak enforcement of labor and tax laws, the informal economy has evolved from necessity into a parallel economic ecosystem. However, its very informality, lack of regulation, taxation, and protections, renders it both a safety net and a bottleneck. With mounting fiscal deficits, dwindling tax-to-GDP ratios, and an expanding youth bulge, assessing the dual identity of the informal sector has never been more urgent.
The informal sector in Pakistan spans agriculture, services, construction, manufacturing, and wholesale trade. It includes entities that operate without registration, lack labor rights compliance, and evade formal taxation. According to the Pakistan Bureau of Statistics' Labour Force Survey (2020–21), approximately 72% of non-agricultural employment is informal. This sector is not only a major source of employment for low-skilled and semi-skilled labor but also functions as a buffer during formal sector contractions, such as during the COVID-19 pandemic or macroeconomic austerity.
However, this economic informality is not a recent phenomenon. It is historically embedded in post-colonial labor structures, persistent underdevelopment, and socio-political patronage systems. The state's failure to provide adequate formal employment and a robust regulatory environment has incentivized informality as both a default economic strategy and a socio-political coping mechanism. As a result, informal enterprises have proliferated in urban slums, peri-urban zones, and rural areas alike.
Key Dimensions of a Shifting Global Landscape
1. A Bulwark Against Unemployment but a Weak Tax Base
One of the primary advantages of the informal economy is its role as a massive absorber of surplus labor, especially in a country with limited formal sector opportunities. From rickshaw drivers and roadside mechanics to informal garment workers and freelancers, it offers a livelihood to those excluded from the formal economy. Especially in rural and underdeveloped areas, the informal economy becomes the default route to survival.
Conversely, the cost to the state is steep. Informal businesses largely evade taxation, contributing to Pakistan's persistently low tax-to-GDP ratio, which hovers around 9.5%, among the lowest in South Asia. This weak revenue generation hampers public investment in infrastructure, education, and health. Furthermore, informal workers are excluded from social security nets such as pensions, healthcare, or unemployment insurance, rendering them vulnerable to economic shocks. While informal work creates employment, it undermines state capacity and long-term fiscal planning.
2. Gendered Dimensions of Informality
Women's participation in the labor market in Pakistan is disproportionately concentrated in informal employment, including home-based work, domestic labor, and agriculture. These roles often go unpaid or underpaid and lack legal or contractual recognition. The Home-Based Workers Act, passed in Sindh in 2018, was a landmark legal recognition of this segment, yet implementation remains weak.
Gendered informality in the economy reinforces socio-economic marginalization, denying women not just economic agency but bargaining power, mobility, and access to benefits. Without integrating informal female labor into mainstream economic planning, Pakistan loses out on a significant productivity dividend and continues to perpetuate gender inequities.
3. Innovation, Agility, and the Rise of Informal Enterprises
Despite its structural shortcomings, the informal sector often displays remarkable resilience and innovation, especially in urban microenterprises and the gig economy. Informal traders adapt quickly to market needs, use minimal capital to generate income, and create localized service ecosystems. During economic downturns and global shocks, such as COVID-19, informal networks proved more agile than formal institutions in delivering essential services.
Moreover, digital platforms have enabled the growth of a new generation of informal digital workers, including content creators, online sellers, and freelancers. These actors operate outside traditional employment models yet contribute significantly to consumption and income flows. While still informal in tax terms, this digital layer may offer a bridge to semi-formality through targeted regulation and incentives.
4. Barriers to Transitioning to Formality
One major obstacle to economic formalization is the complexity and cost of compliance. For many small enterprises, registering with tax authorities or adhering to labor laws involves prohibitive bureaucracy, rent-seeking behavior from officials, and little perceived benefit. Therefore, most microbusinesses prefer to remain under the regulatory radar.
Additionally, the absence of tailored financial products and credit access locks these businesses in low-productivity cycles. Without formal credit histories or collateral, informal businesses are excluded from institutional finance, limiting their ability to scale, innovate, or invest in technology. This structural exclusion perpetuates a vicious cycle of low productivity and informality.
500 Free Essays for CSS & PMS by Officers
Read 500+ free, high-scoring essays written by officers and top scorers. A must-have resource for learning CSS and PMS essay writing techniques.
While the informal economy cushions the blow of Pakistan's economic instability, it also entrenches inequality, fiscal weakness, and low productivity in the country. Formalizing without disrupting livelihoods in Pakistan requires a careful balance, involving regulatory simplification, social protection integration, and targeted incentives. A blanket crackdown may shrink livelihoods whereas ignoring informality would deepen structural dysfunction in the country. Pakistan must thus pursue gradual, inclusive formalization strategies that empower rather than penalize the vulnerable.
The informal economy in Pakistan presents a dual reality: a necessary economic scaffold for millions and a systemic impediment to structural transformation. While it provides employment and sustenance to Pakistan, its unregulated nature limits the state's capacity, perpetuates gender and class disparities, and stunts productivity growth. The solution lies not in eradicating informality but in transforming it through inclusive policy, financial innovation, and capacity building. Formalizing the informal economy must become not a coercive act, but a path to economic dignity, resilience, and sustainability. Therefore, recognizing the country's informal sector's contributions while integrating it into the national development vision is essential for achieving Pakistan's equitable and long-term economic progress.
