What CSS & PMS Qualifiers Say About Sir Kazim! Read Now

Should Pakistan abandon coal-based energy projects, including those under CPEC, in favour of accelerated renewable energy to meet climate commitments and ensure long-term energy security? Argue your position with evidence.

Saira Gulab

Saira Gulab | Sir Syed Kazim Ali’s Student | Pharmacy Grad | HowTests Author

View Author

7 July 2026

|

309

Pakistan’s energy sector is trapped in circular debt, import dependence, and inefficiencies that threaten both economic stability and climate goals. A transition toward renewable energy offers a viable pathway to break this cycle through cleaner, cheaper, and decentralized power systems.

Should Pakistan abandon coal-based energy projects, including those under CPEC, in favour of accelerated renewable energy to meet climate commitments and ensure long-term energy security? Argue your position with evidence.

Outline

1-Introduction

2-Understanding Why the Energy Transition Is Required

3- How to achieving Long-Term Energy Security

3.1 Managing the Circular Debt Crisis and Capacity Building

3.1.1 Solar and wind energy deployment in remote areas

3.1.2  Lower infrastructure and maintenance costs

3.1.3  Reduced vulnerability to supply disruptions

3.2 Eliminating Vulnerability to Volatile Global Fuel Markets

3.2.1 Heavy dependence on imported coal

3.2.2 Pressure on foreign exchange reserves

3.2.3 Renewable energy as a means of reducing fuel imports and preserving foreign currency

3.3 Developing Self-Reliant and Decentralized Energy Grids

3.3.1 Reduced dependence on centralized power plants

3.3.2 Improved energy efficiency through shorter transmission distances

3.3.3 Enhanced energy security through independent power generation

4-Honouring Climate Commitments

       4.1 Utilizing Pakistan’s Diverse Geography

4.1.1 Hydropower potential in northern mountainous regions

4.1.2 Solar energy opportunities in plains and deserts

4.1.3 Wind energy potential along coastal belts

4.2  Phasing Out Inefficient Coal-Based Power Plants

4.2.1 High fuel consumption and emissions from existing coal plants

4.2.2 Environmental and economic costs of coal dependence

4.2.3 Benefits of replacing coal with renewable energy 

4.3  Reusing Existing Infrastructure for Renewable Integration

4.3.1 Conversion of retired coal plants into renewable energy hubs

4.3.2 Utilization of existing grid connections

4.3.3 Reduction in infrastructure development costs and timelines

5-Accelerating the Energy Transition: Is the Time Right?

6-Critical Analysis

7-Conclusion  

1- Introduction

For a longer period of time, Pakistan’s energy sector faces perennial challenges including circular debt crisis, vulnerability to volatile global fuel markets, distribution losses, and centralized power grid. These problems significantly contribute to financial burden as well as pose a serious threat to its climate commitments. To strengthen the backbone of the country and align with the Paris agreement on climate change Pakistan has to adopt a resilient, affordable, and environmentally sustainable energy strategy. Transitioning to renewable energy resources like solar and wind energy involving the geographical advantage help break the vicious cycle by contributing in the reduction of greenhouse gas emissions as well as earning credibility for the country on the global stage.

Follow CPF WhatsApp Channel for Daily Exam Updates

Cssprepforum, led by Sir Syed Kazim Ali, supports 70,000+ monthly aspirants with premium CSS/PMS prep. Follow our WhatsApp Channel for daily CSS/PMS updates, solved past papers, expert articles, and free prep resources.

Follow Channel

2- Understanding Why the Energy Transition Is Required 

It is very crucial to understand why transitioning to renewable energy is essential for Pakistan’s long-term energy security and economic stability. The core reason is that renewable energy can help break the cycle of circular debt by reducing transmission losses and lowering the overall cost of electricity generation. It also decreases dependence on imported fuels like coal, which exposes the country to volatile global prices and drains foreign exchange reserves. By developing decentralized solar and wind projects close to demand centres, Pakistan can improve efficiency and reduce pressure on its national grid. Additionally, using its diverse geography for hydropower, solar, and wind allows the country to generate cleaner energy while meeting climate commitments under the Paris Agreement. The transition is also timely because shifting priorities in initiatives like China Pakistan Economic Corridor (CPEC) Phase 2.0 make renewable integration more feasible than before. In short, this shift is necessary to strengthen economic resilience, improve energy reliability, and support environmental sustainability.

Pakistan must urgently transition from its coal based energy system to a decentralized renewable energy based model to resolve the circular debt crisis, reduce reliance on imported fuels, and ensure long-term energy security. This shift, supported by strong governance reforms and a phased restructuring of the power sector, will help lower electricity costs, improve grid efficiency, and enable Pakistan to meet its climate commitments under the Paris Agreement. 

3- How to achieve long term energy security

3.1 National Circular debt crisis management and capacity building

Renewable energy sources are having a cure for the circular debt crisis by halting different steps in this cascading process thus shaking the entire vicious cycle. For instance by setting up renewable energy projects like solar near to industrial and rural load centres reduces the distance electricity has to travel. This directly mitigates transmission and distribution losses. Similarly by using wind for power generation in rural areas reducing the cost of installation of electricity transmission lines to villages as well as preventing the disruptions caused by natural disasters damaging the supply lines.

3.1 By eliminating vulnerability to volatile global fuel markets

Pakistan relies heavily on imported coal to fuel major independent power plants. Since most countries are signatories to the Paris Agreement, they are generally hesitant to export coal. Consequently, Pakistan is often required to buy coal under the terms dictated by the supplying country. Likewise fuel import requires foreign currency to deal in thus shaking the already fluctuating foreign exchange reserves of Pakistan. Transitioning to renewable energy resources directly displaces coal in Pakistan’s power grid by reducing the burden of import and preserving foreign exchange reserves of the country.

3.2 Self-reliant and decentralized renewable grids

The renewable energy resources like wind and solar can be installed near the point of consumption. This would decrease reliance on distant and centralized power plants, and long term energy security is ensured as these power generating resources operate independently from the main utility grid.   As the electricity does not have to travel hundreds of miles through extensive high-voltage transmission lines, energy efficiency is significantly improved. And reduced the cost of installation and maintenance of main energy production houses.

4- Honouring the climate commitment 

4.1 Using diverse geography of the country

Pakistan’s diverse geography proved to be an evergreen asset for shifting towards renewable energy. High-altitude northern mountains of the country contain massive hydropower potential, plains and deserts are perfect for solar, and long coastal belts host strong wind corridors. Using topographical heterogeneity enables the country to transition to clean power. Using the landscapes of the country for energy is highly cost-effective as it effectively eliminates reliance on imported fuels for energy production as well as protecting from international fuel price fluctuations.  In addition, this approach towards adoption of clean energy help align Pakistan with its climate commitment of achieving a cumulative 50% reduction in carbon emissions from coal-based power generation by 2030.

4.2 Phasing Out Inefficient Coal-Based Power Generation grids

Many coal-based power generation grids are inefficient in their production capacity with high fuel consumption and emission of greenhouse gases and air pollutants as well as increased operational costs and environmental impacts. Phasing out these coal grids with renewable energy sources can reduce fuel import dependence, lower carbon emissions, and improve overall grid performance. This action not only reduces the financial burden associated with the maintenance of infrastructure but also encourages Pakistan’s commitment to the Paris agreement.

4.3 Reusing existing infrastructure for renewal integration

As Pakistan has committed to reduce the use of coal for power generation to 50% by 2030, the coal power plants which will be closed can be turned into clean energy hubs by installation of renewable energy running systems. As these plants are already connected to the national electric grid, Pakistan can significantly reduce the time and cost required to build the new infrastructure from scratch. This initiative helps in fixing the economy, providing reliable and cheaper energy as well as align Pakistan with its climate commitments. 

5- Accelerating the Energy Transition: Is the Time Right?

In the first phase of the China-Pakistan Economic Corridor (CPEC), all energy projects within Pakistan were coal-based. Due to Pakistan's commitments under CPEC, as well as various domestic challenges, the country could neither fully nor partially transition away from coal during that period. However, in CPEC Phase II, China itself shifted its focus toward renewable energy, which has reduced the rigidity of Pakistan's obligations under CPEC regarding coal-based energy development.

This is now a crucial time for Pakistan to work toward fulfilling the climate commitments it made under the Paris Agreement and to transition its energy production from coal to renewable energy sources. Such a shift would not only help Pakistan address domestic challenges, particularly the issue of circular debt, but it would also enable the country to meet its commitments under CPEC while strengthening its compliance with international climate obligations and enhancing its standing as a responsible actor in global climate governance.

3.5-Month Extensive Compulsory Subjects Course for CSS Aspirants

Struggling with CSS Compulsory subjects? Crack Pakistan Affairs, Islamiat, GSA & Current Affairs in just 3.5 months with Howfiv’s expert-led course. New batches every April, August & December! Secure your spot now – WhatsApp 0300-6322446!

Join Now

6- Critical analysis

Although renewable energy can strengthen Pakistan's long-term energy security, reduce fuel import dependence, address the circular debt crisis as well as support climate commitments. However, the success of this modernization of the energy sector requires complementary measures like power sector governance reforms, stronger financial and institutional commitments along with the effective transition planning for existing coal based infrastructure.

7- Conclusion

In conclusion, renewable energy offers Pakistan a sustainable solution to both its energy security challenges and the circular debt crisis. By reducing dependence on imported fuels, minimizing transmission losses, promoting decentralized power generation, and utilizing the country’s diverse geographical resources, renewable energy can lower electricity costs and improve grid efficiency. Furthermore, the transition from inefficient coal-based power plants to clean energy sources will help Pakistan fulfil its climate commitments under the Paris Agreement while strengthening economic stability. Therefore, expanding renewable energy is not only an environmental necessity but also a strategic pathway toward long-term energy security, economic resilience, and sustainable national development.

A CSS-25 Written Qualifier’s Experience with Sir Kazim

Hammad Barkat, a government officer and CSS-25 written qualifier, shares how Sir Kazim’s Essay and Precis writing techniques, structured methodology, and evaluation transformed his English preparation and helped him tackle the toughest paper in CSS.

Read Review

How we have reviewed this article!

At HowTests, every submitted article undergoes a careful editorial review to ensure it aligns with our content standards, relevance, and quality guidelines. Our team evaluates the article for accuracy, originality, clarity, and usefulness to competitive exam aspirants. We strongly emphasise human-written, well-researched content, but we may accept AI-assisted submissions if they provide valuable, verifiable, and educational information.
Sources
Article History
Update History
History
7 July 2026

Written By

Saira Gulab

BS Pharmacy (Pharm D)

Teacher | Author

Reviewed by

Sir Ammar Hashmi

Current Affairs Coach & CSS Qualifier

Following are the references used in the editorial, "Pakistan should abandon coal-based energy projects, including those under CPEC, and pursue an accelerated renewable energy path to honour its climate commitments and achieve long-term energy security." Do you agree? Argue your position with evidence".

History
Content Updated On

1st Update: July 7, 2026

Was this Article helpful?

(300 found it helpful)

Share This Article

Comments